to:
gopal.krishna.goswami@pamho.net
cc: Govindaswami108@gmail.com,
bgis1081@gmail.com,
info@bgis.org,
sri.radhe.ids@pamho.net,
madhava@pamho.net,
kapsh
arrow@avanti.org.uk,
secretary@bhaktivedantacollege.com,
office@krishna-avanti.harrow.sch.uk,
bhisma@iskcondelhi.com,
shabhankardas2005@yahoo.com
date: Tue, Mar 25, 2014 at 5:19 PM
subject: BGIS -GURUKUL SCHOOL - VRINDAVAN
mailed-by: gmail.com
hare krishna
all glories to guru and gauranga ,all glories to srila prabhupada
HH Maharaj my humble obeisance on your lotus feet .
I tried to control my feeling and emotion and not to do any vaisnava apradha against the vaisanva devotee, community and gurukul but after thinking millions times I decide to draw your kind attention towards BGI School Gurukul Vrindavan.
HH Maharaj in every lecture we hear from you and other maharaj and senior Grihasta disciple of HDG Srila Prabhupada and senior vaisnava devotee also that we must give good Vedic education to our children so that they become good vaisnava devotee in this kaliyuga and enroll our children in gurukul ,but now I feel it's not wise decision to send our children in gurukul. My self and other devotee and non-devotee parents feel Gurukul is not running as per the instruction given by HDG Srila Prabhupada.
In one of your lecture HH Maharaj you quoted HDG Srila prabhupada lecture :-
741128SB.BOM Lectures
Therefore our system is, Vedic system is from the very beginning, a child, a boy is sent to gurukula to learn. Not that automatically one learns. One must go to gurukula, brahmacari. Brahmacari goes to guru, and he works like a menial servant. He may be a son of a big brahmana or big king, it doesn't matter. The one who goes to gurukula, he immediately becomes the menial servant of guru. This is the system. That means guru can order him to act any, I mean to say, low class service, still he is prepared to do it. This is the business of brahmacari, and he takes all trouble, and childhood, he doesn't mind. Even Krsna, he went to gurukula. To teach us. Krsna, the Supreme Personality of Godhead, what is the use of His going to gurukula? No, He is teaching, apani acari' prabhu jiveri sikhaya. Caitanya Mahaprabhu also accepted guru, teacher, guru more murkha dekhi' karila sasana.
Now BGI School looks like all other materialistic school in India who do the business on the name of education like other private and public school just collect the huge fees only and run the school on name of ISKCON .
HH Maharaj I am listing some information for your kind attention.
Point which is not in compliance by BGIS (website http://www.bgis.org)
Answer HH Maharaj It's not true one Ashram Teacher is handling more then 30-40 students in each class . HH Maharaj in class the ratio is more than 1:30/1:40 because of this children's are unable to concentrate on their studies effectively , Its total Chaos in class during study because of this students get less marks or failed in unit and final examination. HH Maharaj we sent our children's for study not to fail in their academics examination and we spent our hard earned money for their expensive education. I knew few student are getting free of cost education because there parents are directly or indirectly serving in ISKCON Temple who cannot afford the study expenses .We have our deep respect to our god brothers vaisnava for not affording the high class expensive education which is provided to their children by Gurukul.
We appreciate the wonderful effort by the Gurukul management in this regards.
2. Health care:
We provide full time medical care to our students. The doctor uses both allopathic and alternative medications.
We take care of minor illnesses in the school, and serious ones are referred to Health Care professionals under our supervision.
Answer HH Maharaj here I want to inform you that as compared to the number of students, Number of toilets is very less and the ones that they have are filthy and stinky and un-hygienic. Because of this few children's got sick stomach pain vomiting fever and last year specially dengu fever spared in Vrinadavan gurukul and students were admitted in private local hospital in Vrindavan . That time all of sudden we got message to take our children from gurukul and school were closed for 10 days and children study were affected due to this and their mid term examination were there that time .
The children who got sick of Dengue were admitted in hospital and the hospital expenses money were charged from parents. whereas school take extra deposit of health care money at the time of admission. If children are more sick they ask us to take our children for better treatment at our place.
Other mismanagement observations –
A. School does not tell us real progress of our kids if they are really weak and above to fail they should inform well in time. It's very hard to reach the Class Teachers on Sunday sometime to talk our children it depend on their mood and some time they put the mobile in busy mode or switch off or will say that they are not in gurukul now we try to meet our childerns twice in month . HH Maharaj it's not possible to travel so far to meet our children every week in Gurukul its affect our financial situation and we don't want to make them home sick . In home I cut so many expenses and save money to give better education to my child from my hard earning salary . If he is not getting attention in Gurukul then please advise me how to solve this problem. Its sole responsibility of Gurukul to monitor student progress not to blame student for lacking in studies.
In Class teacher in front of other student openly tease the student who are weak in studies which is not good practices they scold the student in front of other student that you will not be promote to next class its humiliating and discourage the student moral and how the student will respect teacher and Gurukul, colleagues . In this age student are like soft mud where ever you twist them they can be mold. Instead of poking, teacher can give extra class or tuition or keep more attention on student and same to be inform us so that we can ask our children to study hard or Gurukul can stop student annual and other holidays vacation. They say to student school will fail them in final examination and they will not be promote to next class. If student is not doing well in his studies parents must be called and infornt of student they should tell us the performance of our children, which never happened.
B. HH Maharaj, I hope you may be aware of last year food posining case when one newcomer gurukuli student mixed poisons in prasadam bucket in prasadam hall and which was noticed by other and same time another boy inform the class teacher prabhuji and prasadam was thrown out and due to this kids not took the prasadam few days in fear of their life. When we enquired this mater Gurukul management staff tried hiding this incident. This is not good practice Maharaj , later they removed the student from gurukul who mixed the poison in prasadam bucket . When I called and Gurukul and enquired Gurukul warden manager HG Ramchandra Das prabhuji he said nothing happened and he was hiding the fact. If any one report this matter to police or local authority it was not good sign to do any apardha against school, my wife had fight with me to bring back our child from gurukul but I convinced her that this is wrong news and I told my son that if mother ask you then say to her that he was joking with her and we visited the Gurukul after seeing him my wife become calm .
C. HH Maharaj last year more than 04 months school was closed in different occasion for summer & winter holidays and other festival also and due to dengue also school was closed . HH Maharaj my question is that why gurukul is giving so much holidays its Gurukul not the holidays school to spent holiday time in some resort or picnic spot because of this student are not getting proper attention in studies and they are lacking in their studies and gets very less marks in terms and final examination ,Children's performance is not good in terms and class examination. Whenever any big festival or holiday comes they say one week in advance please takes your children. Gurukul can arrange Extra classes to cover up the course which is not happened.
D. Student Feedback from class teacher is different, in front of kids they say something and back of the kids they give another feed back which is confusing to whom we have to trust our kid clashram teacher prabhuji.
E. BGIS has our email address in which Ashram / class teacher prabhuji can send us the feedback report about our kids to us and mark copy to principal and Vice principal so that they children can be track on their performance in education and spiritual advancement in gurukul. We too also can keep track of our children progress .HH Maharaj there is lots of communication gap between Children ,Gurukul and parents. During the admission orientation everything was projected in nice way but in practically it's not followed.
F. HH Maharaj, BGIS Principal HG Dr Lila Purusottam Das prabhuji not at all approachable even HG Radha Kanta prabhuji also very rare to interact with him in person and not allowed to meet its embracing us if we cannot interact with them personaly .
G. HH Maharaj another humble request to you is that please advise Gurukul management to serve light prasadam to children's in morning breakfast at the time of entrance test in gurukul prasadam quality was good because parents visited and were served nice krishna prasadam but after some time ,The started serving Khichari prasadam in breakfast once in week with pakora and curd, HH Maharaj Khichari prasadam we can take in afternoon or evening but how the children's will honor the heavy khichari prasadam in morning . All devotee respect the prasadam because its krishna Prasad ,for children's its not good early in the morning they take heavy Prasad instead of light prasadam . We pay money for their boarding and lodging in good sum so we humble request gurukul management to serve light prasadam to student in morning .
H. HH Maharaj Ji I am not sure whether school management inform parents and you about after 11th class onwards student are accommodated 05 kilometer away from Gurukul in another ashram for lodging and boarding . In Vrindavan winter freezing condition students provided with one blanket only. how they can manage in one blanket the freezing cold in winter May I know to management who will take care of their health if they get sick , security and their prasadam is transported by mini van vehicle to their ashram from gurukul kitchen.
I. The school not at all consults the parents before increasing the fees last year they increase huge sum of school fee.
J. There is no Parent Teacher association in the school.
HH Maharaj, it's my humble request to you that please kindly hear my plight of above points and advice the BGIS management to look in the parents' grievances to keep the HDG Srila Prabhupada words in real.It's my another humble request to Gurukul school that they must increase the faculty staff and recruit more teacher so that no student get fail in their respective class and get better education and become good devotee in their life .
I am sorry for marking the CC mail to Mayapur Gurukul ,Bhaktivedanta College Belgium,Krishnavantischool U.K & HHBB Govindaswami Maharaj.
At last HH Maharaj ,I am begging for pardon on your and all vaisanva devotee lotus feet if I did any offence or raised the above observation and suggestion to improve education quality in vrindavan gurukul .
Your lotus feet servant
krishna kant Das